The difference between bone broth and regular broth, or stock, comes down to the length of the cooking time and the addition of acid to the cooking liquid. They taste very similar, though the bone broth has a slightly more intense flavor and a thicker, silkier texture. They can be used interchangeably in recipes. Really, the main difference is that many people consider bone broth to be therapeutic: the longer cooking time of a bone broth allows the collagen and minerals from the bones and connective tissue to dissolve into the liquid.
This website explains that a stock is based on bones, and a broth (bouillon in French) is based on meat. While a broth can be very flavorful, a stock delivers a rich mouthfeel courtesy of the gelatin that is slowly extracted from the bones.
This webpage lists 10 reasons why you should make your own broth.
Here is an EXCELLENT RESOURCE for all broth related questions, Please do read it!
I've been making bone broth for a looooong time - this is the consolidation of all the recipes and advice I've followed over the years with the important parts highlighted in bold. I apologize in advance for the length of this post but there was a lot of information I wanted to share.
The tastiest broth is made with the whole chicken, including the meat, but the bones, especially the feet, are the healthy bits so if you don't have meaty parts, don't worry about it.
If you want the stock to have that unctuous gelatinous quality, you must add chicken feet. The gelatin and collagen in the feet are what create the luscious mouthfeel.
For a darker richer-looking stock, roast the bones first in a 400F oven for about 30 minutes until they're nicely browned. I have found that this darker stock changes the color of what I add it to which is sometimes a good thing and sometimes not. Often, I need a lighter stock that will just add flavor and not color, in risotto for instance.
My friend and I just compared three different broths: one made with whole chickens, feet, and vegetables, simmered for 3 days and then concentrated; one made with whole chicken, no feet and no vegetables, simmered for 24 hours; and one made with only feet and no vegetables, simmered for 12 hours. Comparing these enabled us to make informed decisions regarding what was important when making broth:
The one made with all three components and then concentrated was the best tasting and required the least amount of storage space. The one made with only feet and no vegetables had the best mouthfeel and an acceptable taste. The one made with only chicken rated the lowest with respect to taste and mouthfeel.
We felt that the best broth would be a combination - long simmered whole chickens and vegetables combined with chicken feet simmered for a shorter period of time. If you're consuming broth purely for health, the version made with only feet was the fastest, cheapest and healthiest version.
Today I am making a light stock.
When I make stock, I normally use a 12 quart stock pot which yields about 2 gallons of stock. This pot easily holds two whole chickens and plenty of veggies. If I'm only using one chicken (2-3 lbs) or only feet, I will use a 6-quart pot. If I luck into large amounts of chicken (like when the farm is processing them, or if I find them on sale), I will make an even bigger batch in a 16-quart or 24-quart pot.
In other words, the recipe can be scaled up or down.
Do NOT use an aluminum pot! The aluminum will leach into the broth. I use stainless, you can use enamel ( water bath canner would make a perfect stock pot!) or enameled cast iron. Some people use uncoated cast iron but I worry that the acid will leach too much iron into the stock.
- 2 small (3 pound) pasture raised chickens or 4 pounds of bones including the feet (animals store heavy metals in their bones, so please use clean chickens!)
- 10 quarts (2.5 gallons) spring, filtered, or distilled water (you will be concentrating whatever contaminants are in your water)
- 1 T. mild acid, helps extract minerals and collagen from the bones (I use fresh lemon juice, you can use apple cider vinegar, wine vinegar, or wine; regular vinegar will impart a strong flavor)
OPT - all the ingredients listed below are optional! They add flavor, but I will often make broth with just bones/meat so that the flavor of the broth doesn't interfere with what I'm using it in.
- 1 t. himalayan pink salt
- 6 large scrubbed but unpeeled carrots, cut into chunks
- 2 large unpeeled onions, cut into chunks*
- 2 leeks, white and green parts, cut into chunks**
- 1 bunch celery, including the heart, or 2 medium celeriac, cut into chunks***
- 3 heads garlic, unpeeled, halved through the center
- 1 bunch flat leaf parsley
- 1 small garnet yam or japanese sweet potato cut into chunks
- 6 allspice or juniper berries
- 2 bay leaves
- 6 strips kelp or kombu
- 1 c. medicinal mushrooms (turkey tail, chaga, reishi, etc...)
Do NOT rinse the chicken! Do remove the bag of giblets from the cavity, if there is one, and use elsewhere; you won't be using the giblets for the stock.
Put the whole chickens into your stock pot and cover with 2" of water. If you're using them, do not add the feet or the vegetables yet! Add acid and salt and let the bones sit in the acidic water for one hour. NOTE: I've JUST read that if you don't soak the bones in COLD water before turning on the heat, you need to cook them for much longer to extract the minerals! She claims that, "If the bones are hot, the pores are closed, and the vinegar can’t get in to work its magic." (This woman recommends 2 T. ACV for every quart of water but I have NEVER used that much and no other recipe I've seen recommends that much so take her advice with a grain of salt.)
After one hour, turn heat to high. Do not cover!
|Cover with clean water|
|After 12 hours on the left (the liquid is simmering, NOT boiling) After 24 hours on the right (looks and smells good!)|
Check periodically to insure the water is not boiling - you want a gentle simmer. The water should never boil. Overheating the broth can cause the protein to break down and the broth to become cloudy. If your burner does not have an ultra-low setting and you need to keep the lid ajar to prevent boiling, if the water level drops below the chicken, add more water.
Some recipes advise you to skim but I don't. Using pastured birds there is very little 'scum' so I just strain very well at the end.
Once the chicken is cooked, about 2 hours in, it will smell better.
|Fresh veggies on the left, frozen veggies on the right.|
|All veggies in the pot - almost overflowing! I should have used a 16 quart pot.|
The reason you add these AFTER the bones have finished cooking is that (1) the vegetables can become bitter if they're cooked too long, and (2) the gelatin in the feet will break down if it's cooked too long.
Bring back to a simmer, cover, and leave overnight or up to 24 hours. After you add the vegetables. it will smell delicious!
As you can see, my pot was way too full! So, I left the cover off overnight, and the entire next day. At the end of that 24 hour period the water level had dropped considerably and the stock was very concentrated. Since I always reduce my stock anyway, I was fine with this.
You can see some of the chicken feet in the photo below.
|After 3 days, without adding water|
Turn off the heat. Place a colander over a large bowl. Using tongs, remove as many of the chicken bones as possible, placing them in the colander. They will have disintegrated so don't worry if you don't get them all. Discard the bones. (These bones are now soft enough that you can give them to your dog, if you're inclined to do so.) If you cooked your stock longer than 24 hours, don't try and salvage the meat - it's given everything it had to the broth.
If you cook your broth for 24 hours, and you've been careful not to let it boil, you can use the meat to make chicken salad or some other preparation with added moisture.
|Colander over a large bowl on left, large nutmilk bag over colander on right|
|All veggies out of broth on left, strained broth on right (gorgeous color!)|
You should now have at least 8 quarts of clean broth! (Because I removed the cover for the last 24 hours, I ended up with 5 quarts.)
1. Transfer it to glass jars and either freeze or pressure can it.
2. Remove the fat and then proceed with option 1. To remove the fat you will need to let the stock cool in the fridge overnight and then scrape off the fat, which will have risen to the top and solidified. Save the fat and use it to fry potatoes.
Transfer all the broth to a clean stock pot, bring to a simmer and, leaving the lid OFF, let the liquid reduce by half. You can now proceed with option 1 or 2 above, or you can reduce it further and make your own demiglace or 'bouillon cubes'. If you're going to make demiglace, you must first remove the fat.
|Removing fat from reduced stock on left, defatted stock on right|
(it's easier to remove the fat from a tall narrow container, than a wide bowl....)
At this point, you can transfer the demiglace to ice cube trays and freeze - each cube will reconstitute to approximately 1 cup of broth - or you can pressure can it.
I pressure can it in 1/2 c jars.
|Two layers of jars in my canner: pint jars on bottom, 1/2 cup jars on top|
To reconstitute: 1 demiglace cube, or 1 tablespoon, in a mug with hot water and salt to taste.
* Whenever I peel an onion, I save the outer layers (which are rich in quercetin) and the root end in a bag in the freezer.
** Whenever I use leeks, I save the dark green leaves in a bag in the freezer. In summer, when they're abundant, I will also cut up whole leeks and store them in the freezer.
*** Whenever I use celery, I save the outer stalks and the leaves in the freezer.
During the summer, I freeze bags of clean parsley to use in stock.
Using the above mentioned * tricks, I always have vegetables prepped and ready to use in the freezer whenever I decide to make stock.
Using a pressure cooker will greatly reduce the amount of time it takes to make stock. HOWEVER, a study done by a SeriouseEats contributor rated the stovetop stock better than either pressure cooker or slow cooker:
"It’s been pretty consistent with every test I’ve done on this in the past: pressure cooker will get you to good results *faster*, but not necessarily absolutely better results. To my palate, the broths did taste slightly different: the pressure cooker version was a little sweeter, maybe due to more maillard reactions taking place in the higher heat, but I don’t necessarily think that’s a good or a bad thing, it’s just different."If you're interested in this method, you should read the comments because they are enlightening. One commenter recommended cutting everything as small as possible, including the bones, to get better extraction. Another commenter referenced a study that claimed a modern pressure cooker made better broth than a jiggle-top pressure cooker. A third claims that only a pressure cooker can extract gelatin from BEEF bones, but it doesn't do much better than stovetop for chicken.
The main reason why I don't use a pressure cooker is that I haven't found a stainless one that's big enough. I prefer to make a large amount of broth, concentrate it, and then pressure can it. I will be researching pressure cooked beef bone broth, though, to see whether it improves gelatin extraction.